Bridging Learning and Social Problem-solving through Active-Learning
Consultative Workshop for the Development of Educational Material for Promoting 4R in Primary Education in Bhutan was co-organized by National Environment Commission (NEC) and CCET on 12 September 2019 at Hotel Osel, Thimphu, Bhutan. The workshop was organized as an initial step of a joint project between NEC and CCET to develop a supplementary tool for environmental education at primary schools in Bhutan.
The rapid economic development, population growth and lifestyle change in Bhutan are resulting in rise of municipal solid waste, with the per-capita waste generation increased within the last decade from 0.253 kg/capita/day in 2008 to 0.350 kg/capita/day in 2018. As a result of rapid urbanization, the amount of MSW disposed to Thimphu’s final disposal site at Memelakha has also increased to approximately 50MT/day with the population of more than 100,000, whereas the site was originally designed to accept only 8 to 10 MT/day serving then population of 15,000 at the time of construction in 1994.
In a country where environmental conservation is positioned as one of the four pillars under its development philosophy of Gross National Happiness, establishment of sustainable waste management system and promotion of 4Rs nation-wide are among the key areas of environmental governance in Bhutan.
In this context, the Royal Government of Bhutan, through its National Environment Commission (NEC) has been exerting efforts to address its waste management problems, including development of National Waste Management Strategy and Action Plan which aimed at providing policy framework for waste management at national level, and to align behaviors of different stakeholders based upon the common vision and goals shared among the society. Promotion of Environmental Education (E.E.) targeting young generation has also been positioned as one of the important strategies for promoting 4R (refuse, reduce, reuse and recycle) through raising awareness and enhancing collaboration and behavioral changes of individuals.
E.E. has been promoted as an independent elective subject at primary level in the present educational system in Bhutan targeting grade 9 – 12, while efforts through extra-curricular activities were also initiated to sensitize students, namely Youth Action for 4R. However, the call for introducing nation-wide programs and initiatives specifically targeted for waste reduction, management and monitoring in school context are increasingly visible.
In this context, following a request by NEC, the IGES Centre Collaborating with UNEP on Environmental Technologies (CCET) has initiated a joint project with NEC to develop an educational material for mainstreaming 4R through primary schools education in Bhutan, building upon the tools/experiences of CCET in this domain based on Active-Learning approach – an approach that values experiential learning in complementary to classroom lectures.
Accordingly, the first consultative workshop was organized with the aim of:
- Sharing the current state of and policy responses to the present waste management challenges in Bhutan, and thereby establish a common understanding on the rational for promoting E.E. from the perspective of waste management.
- Establishing a common understanding on the current policy framework and state of E.E. in primary education in Bhutan, both curricular and non-curricular activities.
- Sharing exploratory cases for E.E. based on active learning approach.
- Exploring how Ecology Note can be utilized in the current context, and how the tool can be customized to serve teachers in Bhutan
- Identifying future actions for mainstreaming E.E. in primary school education and others in Bhutan
The workshop was attended by representatives of government institutions, municipalities, primary schools, NGOs and development partners who have been active in waste management and environmental education including Royal Education Council (REC), Clean Bhutan, Sarpang Environment, Royal Society for Protection of Nature (RSPN), Zhung Dratshang, Bhutan Nuns Foundation, Bhutan Red Cross Society, BTFEC, Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA), United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), and World Wildlife Foundation (WWF).
Presentations were delivered on the state of waste management in Bhutan, policy frameworks on waste management and environmental education (EE), current state of EE in Bhutan, and preceding EE efforts by key organizations. Several key suggestions were highlighted during open discussion including importance of 1) institutionalizing EE through potential integration into official curriculum, 2) approaching generation Y and above in complementarity to primary education, 3) collaboration with religious institutions as a strong influencer to people’s value system and daily behavior, 4) reference to upper stream concerns including SCP, 5) reference to emerging waste management issues such as waste-climate nexus and marine plastic pollutions, and 6) inclusion of provocative questions and focus on action-oriented learning rather than mere academism.
 Waste Inventory and Baseline Study for developing National and City Level Waste Management Strategies and Action Plans, NEC, 2018.
 National Waste Management Strategy 2019, NEC (2019)
Waste Management in Primary School Curriculum? Kuensel, 14 September 2019
Hotel Osel, Thimphu, Bhutan
IGES Centre Collaborating with UNEP on Environmental Technologies (CCET)
2108-11 Kamiyamaguchi, Hayama, Kanagawa,
|10:30-10:35||Opening Remark||Kazunobu Onogawa, DIrector, CCET|
|10:35-10:40||Opening Remark||Phento Tshering, Director, NEC|
|10:40-10:50||Framing Presentation||Background, objectives, and outline of the workshop
Ran Yagasa, Policy Researcher, CCET
|Session 1: The State of Waste Management and Environmental Education in Primary Schools|
|11:10-11:25||The State of Waste Management, National Waste Management Strategy, and the Role of Education for Promoting 4R
Ugen Tshomo, NEC
|11:25-11:35||Waste and Waste Management in School Curriculum
Wangpo Tenzin, Curriculum Specialist, Dean, Curriculum Development Center, Royal Education Council
|11:35-12:05||Current State and Issues of Waste Management in Primary Schools in Bhutan
Presentation by Clean Bhutan
Nedup Tshering, Clean Bhutan
|Promotion of Environmental Education in Primary School Education A Case of Phnom Penh Ran Yagasa, Policy Researcher, CCET
Chimi Dorji, Asst. Dzongkhag Environment Officer
|Presentation by RSPN
Deki Dema, Royal Society for Protection of Nature
|Session 2: Responding to Waste Management Challenges through Action and Learning|
|12:15-12:30||Promotion of Environmental Education in Primary School Education A Case of Phnom Penh Ran Yagasa, Policy Researcher, CCET
Ugyen Tshomo, NEC
|12:30-12:50||Promotion of Environmental Education in Primary School Education A Case of Phnom Penh
Ran Yagasa, Policy Researcher, CCET
|12:50-13:50||Q&A and Facilitated Discussion||Facilitator: Premakumara Jagath Dickella Gamaralalage, Programme Manager/Senior Researcher, CCET||PDF (1.2MB)|
|13:50-13:55||Closing Remarks||Thinley Dorji, Director, Waste Management Division, NEC
Kazunobu Onogawa, Director, CCET